A national survey has shown Australian school students with a mental disorder can be almost three years behind in their studies by the time they sit their final NAPLAN test in year 9. Results also showed students with mental disorders had more absences from school and an increased likelihood of self-harm.
The survey, led by the University of Western Australia and Telethon Kids Institute, was the second Australian Child and Adolescent Survey of Mental Health and Wellbeing. It was conducted in 2013-14 and saw 6,310 families with children and adolescents aged four to 17 taking part.
Data was collected on the mental health of children, covering major depressive disorder, anxiety disorders, attention deficit hyperactive disorder (ADHD) and conduct disorder (extreme behaviour such as aggression towards people, destruction of property, theft, or other law-breaking behaviour). Over 5,000 survey participants agreed to provide access to NAPLAN records from 2008 through to 2016.
Students with mental health disorders struggle at school
Mental disorders affected one in seven Australian students. They were prevalent in more males than females. This was largely due to the higher prevalence of ADHD in males, occurring in 12.2% of young males, and 9.3% of adolescent males. The most prevalent mental disorder for females were anxiety disorders, affecting approximately 7-8%.
The biggest change moving from primary to high school years was the increase in major depressive disorder, particularly for females where it went from 1.5% to 5.6%.
School attendance was also affected. Students in years 1 to 6 with a mental disorder missed an average 12 days per year compared with eight days per year for students without a mental disorder. In years 7 to 12, students with a mental disorder missed an average 24 days per year compared with 11 days per year for those without mental disorders.
Students with ADHD and conduct disorder had the lowest academic performance of all mental disorders. Major depressive disorder was associated with increased risks of self-harm and suicidal thoughts and behaviours. Socio-economic factors were shown to impact negatively on academic performance as well.
Academic trajectories showed students with mental health disorders fall increasingly behind their peers as time goes on. Students with a mental disorder in year 3 were, on average, seven to 11 months behind students with no mental disorder. But by year 9, they were an average of 1.5 to 2.8 years behind.
Students who received help for their mental health problems were more likely to improve in their NAPLAN tests over time. Results from the study indicated some students with severe cases of mental disorders who used services in primary school, eventually overtook some students with mild cases of mental disorders who didn’t use any services. But these students rarely overtook their peers who were unaffected by a mental disorder.
Students need more support
Over the last 15 years, the availability and use of services in both the health and education sectors for children with mental health problems and their families has improved substantially. But there are still too many children who do not receive the help they need at the time they most need it. Parents face significant barriers when trying to access services. These include long waiting times, confusion about where to go for help, and problems getting their child to go to a service such as a child or school psychologist.
Early childhood interventions should continue to be improved to allow timely identification of at-risk children, and connect them with services. Mental disorders such as ADHD, conduct disorder, and anxiety disorders often start early in life and persist for many years. Many students with mental disorders are already below their peers in academic achievement in year 3 and then fall further behind as they progress through school.
Teachers are not mental health professionals and should not be expected to diagnose and treat mental disorders. But student mental health is vital to schools achieving their educational goals. Programs such as Mental Health First Aid courses and Mental Health literacy training may help ensure all teachers can identify problems when they occur and seek appropriate help. School counsellors and psychologists also play a critical role.
Existing school-based and health care systems struggle to deal with the large number of children with a mental disorder. Consideration also has to be given to other ways to help children and families. This includes the option of self-guided online or mobile application based programs to supplement cognitive and behavioural based therapies used by psychologists.
This may also alleviate some concerns around the lack of effectiveness of infrequent treatment. Waiting times in between appointments to see psychologists can be longer than a month, which does not necessarily lead to effective treatment of symptoms.
Continuing to improve how we identify, treat and support students with mental health problems is critical to improving our children’s educational outcomes.
Young Minds Matter was funded by the Australian Government Department of Health. This analysis of educational outcomes was funded by the Australian Government Department of Education and Training.
Benjamin Goodsell does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.